Submitted to BFRO by witness on Thursday, March 26, 2009.
Piercing scream heard by twelve people near Mays Lick
COUNTY: Fleming County
LOCATION DETAILS: Please do not publish location.
NEAREST TOWN: Mays Lick
NEAREST ROAD: US 68
OBSERVED: In June of 2005 my family had a strange occurrence. My son and a couple of his friends wanted to camp out down in the woods. My husband and one of the other boys’ dad went down to check on them before we went to bed. It was a full moon out and they were sitting down there with the boys when my husband saw something move between the trees. He wasn’t sure what it was and kept watching when he seen it move between the trees again he could see the moonlight between its legs. They got scared and came up out of the woods. Of course I didn’t believe him so the next day I went down there and found footprints. One was a really good one that we actually poured a mold of. Upon further scouting I found some odd things. There was a bunch of little pieces of tree bark in a circle and it looked and felt like something might have been chewing on it. We found moss rolled back, not tore up just rolled back. And we also found tree limbs stuck in the ground kind of like markers. Our friends didn’t believe us so one night we got a bunch of us together and went down in the same place my husband first saw it. I had been interested so I did some research on the internet and took a little hand held recorder and recorded what was supposed to be Bigfoot screams. Around dusky dark my husband started playing the screams on the recorder he played them a few times and then all of a sudden we heard the most God awful scream we’ve ever heard. It was high pitched and drawn out. Everyone was shocked. I don’t know what it was but it wasn’t too long after that, that a log, about the size of a piece of firewood came down out of the woods and landed by my vehicle. After everyone got calmed back down we were standing around the fire when I thought I saw something just outside of the fire light walking toward the creek. I went and got back in my truck and about 2 minutes later it sounded like it picked up a creek rock and slammed it back down. We all left after that. The next weekend it was around midnight when my husband, my son and a couple of friends drove my truck back down there. Without a fire it was really dark, they had a spotlight and my husbands’ friend was just randomly shining it through the woods when at the same time my husband and another person in the vehicle said, “there it is” so he brought the light back to the spot where they seen it, my husband instantly started the truck up and his friend told him to shut it off and when he did they could hear it running through the woods. They said it was just trashing it way up the hill. But they saw it when he brought the light back down through the woods, it was behind a tree and they said it had red eyes. Another odd thing was that all the grass was laid down flat kind of like in swirls. And there is nothing down there that would lay it down flat. I’ve seen deer bedding before but this was a large area that was flat by the creek. We still go back there sometimes and we haven’t seen anything or any signs like we did that year. Everyone thinks we are crazy which I probably would too if I hadn’t experienced it for myself. Anyways thanks for taking the time to read this sorry its a few years late but it came up in conversation again and I wanted to share my story.
ALSO NOTICED: The only other weird things were that it seemed like when this thing was around there were no insect noises and no lightning bugs lit up it was totally silent in the woods. We also have a lot of coyotes in our area which we usually hear every night yelping but the time when we were having these unusual experiences we heard no coyotes.
OTHER WITNESSES: The first time there were 3 boys and two adult males. The second time when we heard it scream there were about 12 of us. And the third time it was just four. The first time they were sitting around a campfire. The second time we were around a campfire and the third time they were in a truck without any fire just a spotlight.
OTHER STORIES: I have but I think it was a fake story. Back in 1980’s a man in Fairview supposedly saw one taking frozen chicken out of his freezer. I don’t think that is true we never saw anything up close to our homes.
TIME AND CONDITIONS: late night.
ENVIRONMENT: Down in the bottom of the woods a creek runs through there. Back in that area there is a lot of woods. A lot of cedar trees, its hilly except for two bottoms that kind of join one another.
Follow-up investigation report by BFRO Investigator Harold Benny:
I spoke with the witness by phone and found her to be credible. Although the witness observed a wide range of unusual activity, she had no sustained view of the creature. However, she measured the footprint cast at eighteen inches. The husband and wife described the animal as about seven feet tall with wide shoulders, a cone shaped head, and no neck. The apparent red eyes were thought to be a reflection from the white spotlight. An unusual circle of apparently chewed bark was laid out on the ground. Apes often chew bark to obtain minerals. The use of a bright white spotlight probably accounts for the cessation of observable activity in the area.
About BFRO Investigator Harold Benny:
Harold Benny holds two degrees in Zoology and was a Biology teacher for several years. He participated in the following BFRO expeditions: Michigan UP 07, Arkansas I 07, Arkansas II (Oklahoma) 07, N. Florida 08, Missouri 08, Tennessee 09, and Ohio 09. Harold has organized several private Illinois expeditions and in 2006 received the IDNR Volunteer of the Year Award as part of the Montgomery Co. Hunter Education group.
Submitted to BFRO by witness on Thursday, March 26, 2009.